Bitcoin mining company Hut 8 Corp. has filed a motion in a New York federal court to dismiss a class-action lawsuit initiated by its shareholders. The lawsuit, which originated from claims made by short-seller J Capital Research, accuses Hut 8 of overpaying for a company plagued by operational difficulties.
In a December 2 filing, Hut 8 asserted that the report was part of “a calculated effort by J Capital Research to devalue Hut 8’s stock for its own financial benefit.” The company further argued that “This case stems from a short-seller’s attempt to profit at the expense of ordinary shareholders.”
Hut 8 referred to such tactics as “short-and-distort” strategies, explaining that these schemes often lead to shareholder lawsuits that amplify the negative claims made by the short-seller. “These cases are commonly dismissed,” the company stated, requesting that the court do the same in this case.
In January, J Capital Research released a report alleging that Hut 8 overstated the profitability of its acquisition of US Bitcoin Corp. (USBTC), failed to disclose operational issues at a Texas facility, and possibly concealed information about ownership stakes.
Following the report’s publication, Hut 8’s stock price dropped by 23%, triggering multiple shareholder lawsuits in March. The plaintiffs, including individuals who suffered financial losses, argued that all shareholders who purchased Hut 8 shares during the period in question were entitled to compensation.
Hut 8 responded by noting that its stock price has since recovered, increasing by about 300% since the report was released. The company also highlighted that many of its public statements were safeguarded by “safe harbor provisions,” and that USBTC’s operational risks were previously disclosed.
USBTC, which held a 50% stake in a joint venture Bitcoin mining operation in Texas, merged with Hut 8 in November 2023.
Hut 8 maintained that the lawsuit failed to prove that its statements were false when made or that shareholders suffered actual harm. The company also rejected any direct connection between the alleged misstatements and the subsequent stock price drop.
In conclusion, Hut 8 urged the court to dismiss the case entirely, “with prejudice,” asserting that there were no valid grounds for the lawsuit to proceed.
Hut 8 shares (HUT) closed at $25.06 on December 3, marking a 3.6% decrease, though the stock gained 0.5% in after-hours trading, according to Google Finance. Year-to-date, Hut 8 shares have surged nearly 99%, with a 296% increase from a January low of $6.33.